Featured Football Manager Games Review Head SEGA Simulation Sports Interactive

Football Manager 27 in the test: Back to old glory?

Can “Football Manager 27” make up for last year’s deserved disgrace and win back football management fans?

“Football Manager 27” faced a number of challenges this year. After last year’s big disappointment, Sports Interactive had to prove that they were listening to the fans and not just tweaking a few things. So there was a lot at stake this year, because another disappointment like last year would have caused massive long-term damage to the IP. Apparently the developers at Sports Interactive understood the sign correctly. Because we can predict this much: things have improved a lot. What exactly will we tell you in our test.

Source: Sports Interactive

Biggest Challenge: User Interface

Probably the biggest point of criticism from last year was the changed user interface. There were way too many clicks to get to the correct menu we were looking for. Overall, it was too convoluted and too confusing – even the otherwise enthusiastic modders couldn’t do much about it. Instead, many of the virtual managers quickly switched back to the predecessor FM24 and simply updated the data for the 26/27 season. And that’s exactly where Sports Interactive started this year. Although there is still room for improvement, the step is definitely in the right direction and can be fine-tuned for next year.

But from the beginning. A return to the “old” FM24 user interface would have been the simplest solution, but there is a reason why they wanted to move away from it. Accordingly, a modern design was needed that was based on the favored user interface from 2024 and at the same time was clear enough for people to get along with. In addition, the players wanted to immerse themselves more in the action and be part of it all.

Tactical effectiveness

And that’s exactly what the developers achieved this year. The focus is much more on the data, such as reports before and after individual games or more detailed analyzes during the games. This gives us better depth and, above all, a basis for tactical decisions. This was implemented so well that some players even say that “Football Manager 27” is the best title in the series. And therefore even better than the ever-popular FM24. And that’s saying something – especially in view of last year’s catastrophe.

Probably the most important innovation is tactical effectiveness, which shows how familiar our players are with the tactics we use. There is an indicator for each player individually, which ranges from “red” to “green”, i.e. from “little familiar” to “very familiar. This is a useful innovation because it takes into account how appropriately we plan our training. If the training does not match our selected tactics, the players on our team can of course train for a long time without ever slipping into the green zone. That’s why we should always take a look at our training plan ourselves – and not let our employees do everything for us.

Source: Sports Interactive

Get busy training!

However, tactical effectiveness is not just a value that is shown to us. Instead, it has an actual influence on the team’s performance in the games. The better our players are attuned to our tactics, the better their performance in the corresponding games. Which doesn’t mean that a team with poor tactical understanding can’t win. However, victories in the “form” look rather dirty – and the match engine still has one or two weaknesses. No wonder, after all, it’s only the second year with the new engine. But more on that later.

If you’ve never dealt with in-game training before and have always delegated it to your employees, this year is time to take a look at the practical exercises yourself. Don’t worry, the motto here is simply: learning by doing, i.e. we learn how to handle the training correctly simply by trying it out. This is the only way we can really exploit the full potential of our team. If you really don’t care about it, you can always delegate it to your employees, but they will never be as effective as you. At least, as things stand now.

Data, Data, Data

FM27 brings back essential data—such as live match statistics—that allows us to make adjustments during games, creating the best possible conditions for a win. Not only is more data available by default, but the quality of that data is also superior to what we’ve seen before. Furthermore, we can now utilize this information much more effectively—for instance, by making tactical tweaks. We can also prepare our team for both possession-based play and phases without the ball. Additionally, the data provides insights that help us figure out how to get the absolute best out of our players.

For example, we once deployed a central midfielder in a specific, wider central midfield role. However, the data revealed that he was among the worst in the league in terms of physical performance. This led us to one of two conclusions: either he is simply ill-suited for that role, or his training for that position is still insufficient. We can now address this and see if we can find a more appropriate role for him. Admittedly, having to focus on so much data can quickly feel overwhelming—but that is precisely what it takes to be a successful manager. Just give it a try and dive in!

Source: Sports Interactive

Less is more

Fortunately, there is also significantly less happening off the pitch in FM27. This means that player mutinies occur much less frequently than they did in previous iterations. This is primarily because players no longer become unhappy as quickly as they once did. Notifications requiring us to adjust playing time or negotiate new contracts appear less often, which helps alleviate some frustration. Previously, a negative spiral could easily begin the moment a single player became dissatisfied with their playing time, dragging down the morale of the entire squad. While this can still happen, it now takes longer to reach that point. Furthermore, players who are unhappy with their playing time are now more inclined to fight for a spot in the team—or simply accept their current role. On the other hand, we generally receive more news updates regarding leagues, teams, and individual players.

Unity instead of 3D

Let’s turn to the engine—which, since FM26, has been different from what came before. Up until FM24, the game relied on the 3D match engine; however, starting last year, Sports Interactive switched to the Unity match engine. While that engine had some significant shortcomings a year ago, many of those issues have vanished in this year’s iteration, *Football Manager 27*—though not everything is quite where it should be yet. This is particularly noticeable regarding offside goals, generally bizarre goals, and VAR decisions. Furthermore, the awarding of certain cards can be difficult to fathom, and some of the replays look genuinely strange.

While this is certainly frustrating, it’s manageable—especially considering that the developers can still refine these elements—and, overall, it remains a clear improvement over the previous engine. The engine’s new features for spectators and weather, in particular, make the experience far more immersive than before; for instance, you can see fans wearing heavy jackets during winter matches, or watch shadows shift across the pitch as a game progresses.

Source: Sports Interactive

Conclusion

“This year, like most of you, I was rather skeptical about the FM. Of course, this stems from last year, where some things didn’t go as they should – even though I still had fun with the FM26. But this time, Sports Interactive did a lot of things right and listened to the community’s criticism. They listened and made the right adjustments, which we see above all in the redesigned user interface or the “tactical effectiveness” system. Also, that we are more in the action again and things off the pitch have become rarer. The adjustments to the new match engine are also worth mentioning, which represent significant progress – even if there are still a few teething problems. Overall, there is nothing so serious that it would have a negative impact on the fun in the long term. This year we can really recommend the new version without reservation.“

  • Story/Atmosphere: 80/100
  • Game Design: 80/100
  • Balance: 80/100
  • Scope: 90/100
  • Presentation: 80/100

The review key was kindly provided to us by the publisher.

administrator
Geboren als echter Strategiespieler, hege ich mittlerweile auch eine große Liebe zu Rollenspielen. Während meine Ohren nur den Klang von feinsten Gitarrenriffs der Rock- und Metal-Musik vernehmen, verwirre ich sie gelegentlich mit deutschem Sprechgesang. Meine große Liebe zu den Videospielen besiegelte ich mit dem Einstieg als Redakteur bei spieletipps.de. Mittlerweile betreibe ich seit einigen Jahren meine eigene Website. Außerdem könnte man mich als Community Manager kennen.